“Why now?”


When I bought my car a couple of years ago, I was on a test drive with the nice car salesman when he suddenly got a call.

He had a quick convo, put the phone down, then turned back round to me and said:

“Someone just came to view this car.”

I looked at him (but also tried to keep my eyes on the road).

Me: “But you told them it’s taken, right? It’s mine!”

I was quietly panicking.

Salesman: “Yes, I told them. It’s yours if you want it.”
Me: “Okay, great”.

I relaxed. This was a done deal now. I had to buy the car, which was fine with me because I really did want it.

When I got home, I told my husband how extremely lucky I was to have got there 10 minutes before the next buyer.

Husband: “Fake story. He tricked you.”

What?!

No way.

There’s no way that lovely guy…

Hmmm 🤔

Two years later, I still think about this.

I don’t know whether the other buyer was real or not, but I do know the impact the potentially real/potentially fake buyer had on me.

Whether he meant to or not, the car salesman immediately created a sense of urgency and FOMO in me.

Urgency because I suddenly had a reason to buy the car right now. I couldn’t go home and think about whether I wanted it because that other buyer would steal my (not-quite-my) car from under me!

And FOMO because I suddenly couldn’t bear the idea of being without this particular car. I didn’t want anyone else to have it. I wanted it. I needed it.

Whether the other buyer was real or not, it worked.

I bought the car.

And that, Reader, is the power of “Why NOW?”

The power of “why now” applies to email marketing too.

You will not sell (many of) your products or services in emails if you don’t give your subscribers a reason they should buy right now – as opposed to a month or a year from now.

Your emails and your launches need urgency. Or they just won’t work.

This is a hill I’m willing to die on.

(Side note. Let’s define “urgency”. Urgency is a marketing strategy designed to encourage immediate action or engagement from a potential buyer)

Don’t believe urgency is necessary?

Well, I conducted a little experiment with my client, Melissa Oleson, to prove it totally is.

Melissa (a pelvic floor therapist & course creator) had an evergreen funnel that funnelled people in from her Instagram to her emails.

They’d go through her free or paid challenge, then immediately be given the chance to buy her mid-ticket on-demand course.

She did already have an offer set up to create urgency so people could save some money on her course if they bought it in the funnel – but the timeline wasn’t clear and it wasn’t presented in the best way.

Because of that, Melissa was only getting 1 or 2 sales every couple of months when she hired me.

We worked together for a few months and in that time me and my team redid her challenge emails, her sales sequence, and her sales page.

But the biggest change to her funnel was the added (and clear presentation of) urgency.

We added countdown timers to the emails and made it super clear that there was:

  • A limited discount (save $100)
  • And limited time (7 days)

Today, Melissa is now getting anything from 5 to 10 passive sales a WEEK just from email. (That’s up from one or two sales every couple of months).

And no, Melissa was not using paid ads.

It’s just her, an engaged audience, and the right amount of urgency in her marketing.

That’s the power of “why now?”

Whenever you’re selling something, give your subscribers a valid question to the answer “why now?” and you’ll see an uptick in sales.

Some people say urgency is an unethical marketing practice – and yes, it can be.

But it doesn’t have to be when you make the conscious effort to stay away from pressuring people into making bad (and big) money decisions.

You can make sales and not be like the car salesman who makes up fake reasons to get you to buy.

We can talk more about how to make your urgency not feel icky next week if you’d like? 🙂

Eman

PS. We’ve got a spot open for a new email project! Want it to be yours? Get in touch here


Wait a sec, Reader! Here are some ways I can support you and your business 😄👇🏽

💌 My strategy and copy helped this coach and course creator generate $2.5 MILLION (and counting!). Let's talk about working together if we aren't already?

📞 Want tailored strategy recommendations so you can get more (and make more) from your emails? Book an Email Strategy Consult

🌟 Wanna earn more and work less by offering a high-ticket VIP Week to clients? Grab my instant access masterclass, Design Your VIP Week. (Made for service providers & consultants).

🎙 Listen to my multi-award-winning podcast Mistakes That Made Me – where I ask extraordinary business owners to share their biggest business mistake.

Check out the first episode with Vivian Kaye where she talks about her $12,000 mistake 😱

🔐 Try my podcast's private membership for just $1 and unlock exclusive WEEKLY bonus content. If you love my emails and my podcast, you'll love this membership.

The Email Rules

I've helped business owners like you make MILLIONS of dollars with my email strategy & copy skills. Join my newsletter and learn how to make more money with better (DIY) emails for your business. If you like a good story & a great business lesson, this is the newsletter for you.

Read more from The Email Rules

Some business owners who want to join Design Your VIP Week 2025 are worried about the price tag because they need to keep their business expenses low right now. (I totally get that). Others want a guarantee that they're going to get a return on investment. I can't give you that guarantee because I can't see into your future – but what I *can* do is look to the past and see what past Design Your VIP Week students have been able to achieve after completing the masterclass. Here's what you need...

With the devastating LA wildfires, an age-old debate has resurfaced among business owners (as it does every few months): “Should businesses pause their email marketing to be sensitive towards those impacted?” (If you or someone you know has been affected by the wildfires, I’m so sorry. I hope you/they are safe). It’s hard to know what to do sometimes. A lot of businesses keep going… Many others privately press pause on their email broadcasts and campaigns. Then there’s the very vocal group of...

Almost a year ago, I got a private message from one of my Instagram followers (someone I don’t know) pressuring me to post about the genocide in Gaza. The message annoyed me because, quite frankly, I don’t like strangers telling me what to do. I didn’t reply to the message. So this person copied and pasted it, and sent me the same message again. Again, I didn’t respond because I didn’t feel like I owed her a conversation. (I have over 18,000 followers across my social platforms and email...